Tyson, curious if you've been able to compare the MP DAC with the May DAC?
My buddy Mike Galusha has a Holo May DAC and a Holo Spring DAC in his 2 systems, I got to hear both of them over the past 2 visits to his house. He's also my tube guy and does all the measurement for all the crazy gear I buy. Lovely man. Funny story - we both started out with Auralic Vega DAC's several years ago, and we are both big lovers of tube amps and high efficiency speakers that have been optimized to have beautiful tone in addition to their killer dynamics. He went from the original Vega to the Vega G2 and I went from the original Vega to an iFi iDSD Pro (because, tubes!). Now I've got the MP and the iFi both and he's moved on to the Holo DACs.
The Holo DACs are very good. I mean really, really good. If there were no great quality tube DACs out there, I would certainly get the Holo May based on what I heard at Mike's. Very clear, very dynamic, insane soundstage, just a super-high resolution device in the very best sense of the term. When I got my iFi iDSD Pro, I told myself I would never buy a non-tube based DAC again. But the Holo is so good, I've changed my mind. I could easily live with it.
BUT, given that I can afford either of them, which would I choose? Oh, the iFi and the MP would be my first choices. They just sound closer to what I ultimately want my music to sound like. So I give up a bit of resolution and bit of dynamics and what I gain is tone. Glorious, beautiful, soul-moving tone. For me, this makes the emotional intensity of a performance so much higher, and that's what I'm really after.
I had 2 iFi iDSD Pro's, one for my upstairs system with the X3's and a 2nd for my downstairs system with the Super 7's. I'm selling both of them. Why? Because I'm moving up to the iFi iDSD Pro Signature (just released by iFi) in my downstairs system, and keeping the MP in my upstairs system. The reason I was getting the MP in the first place is I don't have room for a preamp in my upstairs system and most DAC's are too wimpy to drive an amp directly. You can to it, but most of them kind of suck at it. The MP is WAY overbuilt for a DAC, but that makes it just about perfect to drive an amp directly. I've been very happy with my unit so far.