Hi Guys,
I watched part of the game where James Holmes debuted for St Kilda and he played quite reasonable. Still very raw at the moment but the guy can leap so high (tap ruck man) and has good potential. Yes he is the first American to play Australian Rules Football (AFL). The aussie rules football is weighted quite a bit heavier than Grid Iron and will take a while for him to transition to it.
There have been a few AFL players who have played grid iron in the USA most notably Darren Bennett who was the first to convert to your game.
Cheers Rod