KOTOR clearly deserved GOTY. With the proliferation of ho hum shooters in videogames, it's nice to see a classic RPG win. I may also add that, like Woodsea, I think PoP is a masterwork as well, though I think that I ultimately liked Legend of Zelda WW a bit more.
You have 2 Xboxes, Rob? Dang! Get a GCN! You are missing out on some fabulous games(e.g., Metroid Prime, Viewtiful Joe, Eternal Darkness,etc.).