Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic. Read 16747 times.

dB Cooper

Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #20 on: 2 Sep 2016, 11:52 pm »
Local hardware barn should have something more oriented towards home hardware use.

Fullrangeman, can you share which Bozak speaker models you have heard? I'm wondering what the basis for your blanket dismissal of them is. Has speaker technology advanced in the last fifty years? Certainly. Are there still well-designed vintage speakers that can provide an enjoyable, if perhaps not state-of-the-art, musical experience? Sure.

FullRangeMan

  • Volunteer
  • Posts: 19926
  • To whom more was given more will be required.
    • Never go to a psychiatrist, adopt a straycat or dog. On the street they live only two years average.
Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #21 on: 3 Sep 2016, 04:14 am »
Local hardware barn should have something more oriented towards home hardware use.

Fullrangeman, can you share which Bozak speaker models you have heard? I'm wondering what the basis for your blanket dismissal of them is. Has speaker technology advanced in the last fifty years? Certainly. Are there still well-designed vintage speakers that can provide an enjoyable, if perhaps not state-of-the-art, musical experience? Sure.
I have listen none Bozak, just JBL vintage Alnico woofer.
Iam familiar w/magnets sound's in hi-fi and pro-audio, of course Alnico & Ferrite magnets advanced since today, not to mention Neo.
So the situation we have today concerning magnets SQ are:
Alnico for rich harmonic content,
Ferrite for low price,
Neo Dymium for detail.

dB Cooper

Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #22 on: 3 Sep 2016, 10:13 am »
I have listen none Bozak, just JBL vintage Alnico woofer.
Iam familiar w/magnets sound's in hi-fi and pro-audio, of course Alnico & Ferrite magnets advanced since today, not to mention Neo.
So the situation we have today concerning magnets SQ are:
Alnico for rich harmonic content,
Ferrite for low price,
Neo Dymium for detail.
So, with all due respect, I don't see how you can comment that "The sound of Bozak speakers are not good in a broad sense" when you have (by your own admission) never heard any. While speaker design and technology has undoubtedly advanced over the years, the Bozak line was highly regarded in its day, and it seems to me that the best way to meaningfully judge the SQ of a given piece of equipment- modern or vintage- is by actually listening to it.

ohenry

Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #23 on: 3 Sep 2016, 01:10 pm »
Bozaks are pretty good.  They hit the mark with other quality speakers of that vintage.  They can be helped with some renovation and made better.  I have a soft spot for appreciating and enjoying old things.  For less money and good times, it's just fun to preserve.

If you love music, Bozaks abide.  :D

FullRangeMan

  • Volunteer
  • Posts: 19926
  • To whom more was given more will be required.
    • Never go to a psychiatrist, adopt a straycat or dog. On the street they live only two years average.
Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #24 on: 3 Sep 2016, 03:43 pm »
So, with all due respect, I don't see how you can comment that "The sound of Bozak speakers are not good in a broad sense" when you have (by your own admission) never heard any. While speaker design and technology has undoubtedly advanced over the years, the Bozak line was highly regarded in its day, and it seems to me that the best way to meaningfully judge the SQ of a given piece of equipment- modern or vintage- is by actually listening to it.
I mean say Bozak w/Alnico magnet has good sound and the Ferrite magnets speaker has the usual sound that these magnet are known.
The main factor in determine sound in a speaker specially woofer and midrange is the magnet type. I follow us, uk and portugal audio scene since the 1970s and Bozak despite being a better product than Bose or HT speakers is not au pair with Infinity IRS, B&W, Magnepan, Quad, Klipsch, Polk, Kef, Monitor Audio, Dynaudio, Apogee etc to stay w/famous brands only of that era. It just happen Bozak had a well made ads in magazines emphasizing its appearance and a efficient made text to convince the audiophile that the product is extraordinary.
But if you believe Bozak are the sweet spot it will be for you.

Dmason

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 1282
Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #25 on: 3 Sep 2016, 03:53 pm »
Their 12 inch Alnico woofer with hemp/wool cone, and their 6 inch treated aluminum cone, widerange midrange ...B200 and B199 I believe, are extraordinary drivers, to this day. A modern speaker ---> designed around these drivers, especially an OB using the 12, using a high damping factor chip amp, I think, would be fantastic.

SteveFord

  • Facilitator
  • Posts: 6389
  • The poodle bites, the poodle chews it.
Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #26 on: 3 Sep 2016, 04:03 pm »
I haven't heard any Bozaks but I'd like to.
That certainly looks like a piece worth preserving. 

Phil

Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #27 on: 3 Sep 2016, 05:52 pm »
 
I will say this about the clarity of the sound.  When I leave my house I frequently leave a stereo on to make any would-be intruders ask themselves if anyone is home.  If I leave my modern stereo on, with speakers ranging from 10-20 years old I stand outside and the sound is muffled compared to the Bozaks at the same volume.  They are clear as a bell when standing outside the door and being powered by an old Kenwood KR-4400 receiver.  Even switching back and forth between the two units with the local classical station tuned in the difference is remarkable.  I question if the Bozaks would sound as good with modern music coming from a CD player, but one day I might risk defilement and connect the CD player to them and find out.
This took me back to my childhood.  My dad had a Bozak that looks exactly like yours.  He changed the door to the bedroom closet and mounted it there.  One of the wires from the midrange/tweeter set hung across the room to a cabinet the size of a washing machine that held the woofer part of the system (the capacitor, or whatever is was, suspended in air).  Don't know what the acoustic stuff in the woofer cabinet was but our cat usually started her kittens off there.  At any rate, re the clarity.  Back in the day, my dad would crank up the system (simple tubed amp and preamp + TT) to let's call it realistic levels.  He had a test record which was the sound of a train.  Apparently one of our neighbors had a bit of a bad day when he was on the toilet and thought a train was coming through his house and decided to leave his house.  My dad loved that story and it still makes me laugh.  Crazy audiophiles and understanding wives, to say the least.  To think that got me started in this weird hobby is amazing.  Enjoy your speakers.  From (ancient) memory, they sounded lovely - realistic and dynamic.   

hdspeakerman

Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #28 on: 3 Sep 2016, 07:17 pm »
I have a pair of Bozak speakers and I think their reproductions of piano music is
more realistic than any of the speakers I have ever owned.

Dmason

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 1282
Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #29 on: 3 Sep 2016, 11:01 pm »
The ones I heard I think were called 302B, had the 12 but not the weird twin tweeters, the 6 midrange, and another, super serious looking tweeter. that thing looked very much like a rock bit, had it said "Hughes Tool" I wouldnt have been surprised. It was glorious, and was I believe powered by a quality Telefunken PP EL84 twould have been. In a  Scottish audiophile doctor's basement. This was great sound, by all means.

ohenry

Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #30 on: 3 Sep 2016, 11:17 pm »
Hey Dan, it's good to see that you're back.   8)

I bought a nice pair of Concert Grands a few days ago in a fit of insanity.  The mighty Boz abides and my doctors have job security.  :D

fishmonster

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 13
Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #31 on: 4 Sep 2016, 12:27 am »
I mean say Bozak w/Alnico magnet has good sound and the Ferrite magnets speaker has the usual sound that these magnet are known.
The main factor in determine sound in a speaker specially woofer and midrange is the magnet type. I follow us, uk and portugal audio scene since the 1970s and Bozak despite being a better product than Bose or HT speakers is not au pair with Infinity IRS, B&W, Magnepan, Quad, Klipsch, Polk, Kef, Monitor Audio, Dynaudio, Apogee etc to stay w/famous brands only of that era. It just happen Bozak had a well made ads in magazines emphasizing its appearance and a efficient made text to convince the audiophile that the product is extraordinary.
But if you believe Bozak are the sweet spot it will be for you.

I have to agree with dB Cooper on this one.  If you haven't heard them there is no basis for comparison.  Granted, there are two parts to what makes a speaker good/great.  There is "X", the science/technology part, and then there is "Y", the beholder part.  Ultimately, naming the "best" speaker may be like trying to name the best pipe organ, the best bottle of scotch or the best cigar because the "Y" part of the equation isn't really tangible.  I don't know where you live FullRangeMan.  I've also never experienced the Concert Grands, but you might try searching in your area for some Concert Grands and ask if you can listen to them.  Not to be cliche', but in terms of classical music I think I would test them out with Dvorak's 9th Symphony, Tchaikovsky's 1812 Overture or even Gershwin's Rhapsody In Blue, as that was something Bozak himself probably used.  If you have 15 minutes on your hands I'd say that a solid performance of Ravel's Bolero would also be good, with the volume set at finale levels so you can experience the range.  For rock I'd say The Who's Quadrophenia, the Grateful Dead's Terrapin Station or something like Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon, or anything that has that wall of sound feel.  Short of that, I'd suggest reading this review: http://www.stereophile.com/historical/1005bozak/.  It's a few pages, but it is well written and after listening to my low end Bozaks I think I understand where the writer is coming from.  The one word he uses to describe the sound he heard from the Concert Grands is "effortless".  It's almost like the sound is just there, and not coming from a speaker at all. 

fishmonster

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 13
Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #32 on: 4 Sep 2016, 12:33 am »
He had a test record which was the sound of a train.  Apparently one of our neighbors had a bit of a bad day when he was on the toilet and thought a train was coming through his house and decided to leave his house.  My dad loved that story and it still makes me laugh.  Crazy audiophiles and understanding wives, to say the least.  To think that got me started in this weird hobby is amazing.  Enjoy your speakers.  From (ancient) memory, they sounded lovely - realistic and dynamic.   

Phil, you might want to check that record because you just might have a piece of history yourself.  Check this out from the Wikipedia page:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rudy_Bozak
Quote
Bozak met Emory Cook in the early 1950s; the two hit it off and began working in a shared warehouse basement facility in Stamford. Cook and Bozak thrilled the audio world in 1951 with Cook's ground-breaking stereo recording of train sounds at night: Rail Dynamics. Together, Bozak and Cook implemented a stereo loudspeaker system that would be able to show Cook's stereo recordings to best effect.

It's probably good that they recorded the train sounds at night because the hobos would have been passed out by then.

dB Cooper

Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #33 on: 4 Sep 2016, 03:12 am »
I mean say Bozak w/Alnico magnet has good sound and the Ferrite magnets speaker has the usual sound that these magnet are known.
The main factor in determine sound in a speaker specially woofer and midrange is the magnet type. I follow us, uk and portugal audio scene since the 1970s and Bozak despite being a better product than Bose or HT speakers is not au pair with Infinity IRS, B&W, Magnepan, Quad, Klipsch, Polk, Kef, Monitor Audio, Dynaudio, Apogee etc to stay w/famous brands only of that era. It just happen Bozak had a well made ads in magazines emphasizing its appearance and a efficient made text to convince the audiophile that the product is extraordinary.
But if you believe Bozak are the sweet spot it will be for you.
I don't recall saying any of that, and I'm also not the one making pronouncements about the sound quality of speakers I have never heard. The fact that fishmonster's speakers still work after ~50 years says something about their build quality if nothing else. I'm also skeptical that magnet material is the be-all of speaker SQ, more than driver choice, crossover implementation, cabinet tuning, cone profile, driver layout etc etc etc. I doubt the JBLs you mentioned, the Bozaks, or the Dyna A25s I started out with all sound the same even though they all have alnico magnets. Everybody's entitled to their opinions, but without direct firsthand experience I don't see how you can even have that.

fishmonster

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 13
Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #34 on: 4 Sep 2016, 05:11 am »
I'm also skeptical that magnet material is the be-all of speaker SQ, more than driver choice, crossover implementation, cabinet tuning, cone profile, driver layout etc etc etc. I doubt the JBLs you mentioned, the Bozaks, or the Dyna A25s I started out with all sound the same even though they all have alnico magnets.

You are right on target with this observation.  I think that Bozak's proprietary blend of paper pulp, lamb's wool and secret construction methods for the cones are as important to the Bozak sound as anything else.  That lamb's wool in the cones just strikes me as brilliant for strength and flexibility in the resonance that the cones provide.  The drivers and crossovers are also just as important.  And I don't think we can leave out the finely tuned ears of Rudy Bozak and his years of expertise as an audio engineer, either.  Not to sound sexist, but if Rudy Bozak had a son in addition to his daughters, and that son was inclined to follow his dad into the family business we might still be listening to Bozak speakers to this day.  Between the article in Vacuum Tube Valley and the Wikipedia article on Rudy Bozak I get the distinct impression that he was disheartened and felt abandoned when he sold the company.  They relegated him to a back room in his final years and basically covered any contributions he could have made with a wet blanket.  In fact, I think his strength was in seeing a challenge and rising to meet it.  His work at two World Fairs and designing the audio for the Pope might have been, in his eyes the greatest moments of his professional career.  When speaker technology started changing in the 1970's he may have been somewhat flummoxed in applying his expertise.  But if he had a son running the company and who came to him for his expertise in bridging the technological generations the story would have ended far differently than it did.  Without a problem to solve he may have felt useless, which for an older man of his generation is the equivalent of a death sentence.

Rocket

Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #35 on: 4 Sep 2016, 05:22 am »
Hi,

Thank you for providing this information as I found it really informative.

Cheers Rod

Guy 13

Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #36 on: 4 Sep 2016, 07:26 am »
May I add something here ?
It's not because a manufacturer doesn't exist any more
that the products he built are no good today.
I remember when I was working at Cité Électronique in Montréal, Canada in 1967
of RSC (Radio Speaker of Canada) with their models:
Santa Maria, Nina and Pinta, I thought at the time that they sounded very good.
They went out of business, don't know why, but you can still find some use units,
minds you very rare.
So Bozak had at the time a very good reputation,
I don't know why it should be different today,
if they were well built and they were, then they are worth buying with or without
modifications - improvements.
Now, I will get of your hair.

Guy 13
on planet Vietnam.

FullRangeMan

  • Volunteer
  • Posts: 19926
  • To whom more was given more will be required.
    • Never go to a psychiatrist, adopt a straycat or dog. On the street they live only two years average.
Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #37 on: 4 Sep 2016, 11:10 am »
I don't recall saying any of that, and I'm also not the one making pronouncements about the sound quality of speakers I have never heard. The fact that fishmonster's speakers still work after ~50 years says something about their build quality if nothing else. I'm also skeptical that magnet material is the be-all of speaker SQ, more than driver choice, crossover implementation, cabinet tuning, cone profile, driver layout etc etc etc. I doubt the JBLs you mentioned, the Bozaks, or the Dyna A25s I started out with all sound the same even though they all have alnico magnets. Everybody's entitled to their opinions, but without direct firsthand experience I don't see how you can even have that.
Unfortunately it is(magnets), its impossible to made a ferrite driver sound like an Alnico, they have totally different sound character and project approach, it would be a bliss if possible.

Phil

Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #38 on: 4 Sep 2016, 09:42 pm »
Phil, you might want to check that record because you just might have a piece of history yourself.  Check this out from the Wikipedia page:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rudy_Bozak
It's probably good that they recorded the train sounds at night because the hobos would have been passed out by then.
Thank you for the link to an interesting factoid.  Clearly they succeeded in producing a "dynamic" speaker.  My dad's system filled the entire (small) house with sound.  The system was in the bedroom  on the second floor and I could enjoy what we called Church music (classical played on Sundays) downstairs.  When I was recently talking with my dad about amplifier power, he was surprised that speakers needed more than 10 watts to get going.  "My Boak's didn't need so much power," he commented.  Indeed they didn't.   

KenSeger

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 271
  • Heavy and noisy, but beautiful
    • Ken's Plain Jane Website
Re: Anyone good at identifying ancient Bozak speakers?
« Reply #39 on: 12 Aug 2019, 02:45 pm »
Fishmonster,  I don't mean to rain on your parade, but several items.
1. the paper-coned shiny dust cap B-200X tweeters from the 1950s are terrible in comparison to the B-200Y (60s), or B-200Z (70s).  Whether it was they are from the 50s and were only designed to get up to 8kHz or whether 50+ years of oxidation has taken its toll on the cone, I do not know.  If you use them only below 7kHz they are tolerable.  B-200Ys are plentiful and vastly better.
2. Rudy Bozak never used fiberglass as acoustic damping.  In the 50s he used Kimsul a pleated paper affair, that turns, literally, to dust by now.  From the 60's onward he us Tufflex a woven cotton mat.  If you want to get what the Bozaks are capable of, dump the fiberglass and get some cotton batting and put that on all interior surfaces, except the front, and hang a curtain of it about 4-6" from the back.  The woofer is designed to be in an infinite baffle enclosure and the idea is to eliminate the back wave.
3. Most Bozaks out there sound muffled and indistinct because they have the original capacitors.  If they have your oil caps (the N-4) they are so old  even though oil caps self heal, they only do that for so long and then die.  The new partners in the 60s made Bozak go from oil caps to conventional.  Unfortunately they choose a model of cap from Chicago Condensor Corporation that aged really fast and really badly. The so-called dirty yellow crayon.  I never would have bought my Concert Grands based on what they sounded like 14 years ago with their 31 year old caps.  But I knew what they sounded like back when I sold them (we also sold Klipsch, B&O, Magneplanar, Magnepan, ADS/Bruan, Audionics, Canton) so I knew that 2 new caps per box (6db/oct crossovers) and they would sound like they should sound.  Also the new partners decided to wire the midrange out of polarity (remember this is a 6db/oct crossover) which gave it more midrange "punch" (I.E., peakiness) which ruined the imaging IMHO.  In the 70s a different brand/model of cap was used, that didn't age much better. Shiny yellow crayon.
I think your model with the top ridge was either a custom order or a home-brew and there is nothing the matter with home-brew if the walls are strong and rigid.
Let me know if you want to work on these yourself to get these in better shape.  The optimum would be to add a B-209B or B-209C midrange with a small back chamber. The B-209A was a built for 3 years oxidizing disaster that was made before plastic antioxidants were understood, and the old paper-coned B-209 midrange is too old and does not have any of the definition of the spun aluminum coned B-209B/C.
Best way to contact me is on Facebook or a message here on AudioCircle.
Best Wishes,
Ken Seger
P.S. Hint. Rotate the woofer 180 degrees every fifty years to prevent spider/surround sag, so that gravity starts pulling from the opposite direction.