Hi Tony: I enjoy them both, myself. Each has it's own charms. Live, I'd give the edge to the White Stripes. A lot of bands should be so lucky as to put out an album as good as El Camino in their careers.
The thing I like best about both of these bands is that they haven't lost the connection to what made a lot of that early music you refer to so potent. And so timeless.
D.D.
Diamond Dog and BrysTony many thanks for the Black Keys suggestion. I just acquired El Camino and am enjoying it immensely! Great music and thanks again for the recommendation. I will be checking out their "Brothers" album next.
I can hear some similarities to the Stripes but they are different enough to be unique. After watching the documentary "It Might Get Loud" about the Edge, Jimmy Page and Jack White I have even more appreciation for Jack White and his music with the Stripes, The Raconteurs and as a solo artist but I like the Black Keys better. And this is from someone who has four Stripes albums and "Broken Boy Soldiers" by The Raconteurs. You guys rock!
Please continue with the recommendations.