I'll add my 2 cents for the heck of it...
I essentially left this hobby 2 yrs ago. back then, people had been discussing the same things for some time. I really hoped that by now enough people would have experimented w/break in so we wouldn't still be spinning in circles. This is disconcerting to say the least.
i've owned hagermans FryBaby for about 5 yrs, and recently purchased his FryCorder. burn-in is no myth to my young ears, and TBH i cannot stand to just let a component burn-in with normal playtime...its a waste of time & often uncomfortable. Suffering through burn-in just doesn't make sense. We take aspirin when we have a headache, right?? Why not use a burn in tool to put this debate to rest?
Dave may be correct in that its FM. Personally, i think there is a physical change that occurs at some level to the conductors & dielectric...but of course that hasn't been proven.
What i do know is whether you are running a power cord (for example) with a refrigerator or a generator (or whatever) it will never be fully run in. I've tried all sorts of difft methods, and the only ones that were reliable & predictable are when i used either the Frybaby or the FryCorder. I do agree with Dave that no matter what method of burn in you use, plugging the component in & using it as normal for a while is the last step.
The 'baby uses a 2volt signal, the 'Corder uses a 1 watt signal. Neither are large, and according to J Hageman cables cannot be overburned w/his system. I've read several accounts, back in the day, of people cooking cables with high currrent & 'bleaching' the sound...which wasn't reversible.
I think its due to anecdotes like these that people shy away, and that's too bad...cause we've all experienced the new gear doldrums, and then the 'month later' revelations.
I can't offer any concrete evidence or theories as to why it works. If you read J hagermans white papers on the subject, he states that a # of difft things could be occurring, and that to figure it out might require experts in many difft fields of study.
I can only toss out a good line from the movie 'Tommy Boy': "I don't have to stick my head up a cow's arse to find out how good the T bone steak is...I'll just ask the butcher."
Recent experiences w/the FryCorder can be found here:
http://www.audiocircle.com/index.php?topic=90585.0matt