OB with Twin Alphas and Heil AMT

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 16612 times.

bladesmith

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 1378
  • water quenching steel since 2001....
    • palmer knives
Re: OB with Twin Alphas and Heil AMT
« Reply #20 on: 13 Dec 2014, 08:11 am »
For various reasons, I settled on the following for my latest OB experiment:

One Alpha 15A
One Dayton AMTPRO-4

Baffles are ~ 20" wide, 42 inches tall. They are tapered so they are ~12 inches wide at the top of the panel.
Currently using a simple coil/cap arrangement with the drivers rolling in/out around 4-5 KHz.

With this arrangement, I guess I just got lucky with the efficiency/xover points/slopes and the drivers match well with no need for padding down the AMT.

I can post pix if anyone is interested but so far, I am very impressed with how good these sound.  I am still using a sealed ML sub for < 50 Hz. Setting up a local listening panel soon to A/B these with Maggies, Logans, and a few other single driver setups. You really need to discount the pride factor when you build your own. But right now I would say that these are Maggie killers. All of the open and boxless sound of Maggies with much more bass, efficiency, depth, dynamics, and better and more extended highs.

I have also been trying to determine if the AMTPRO driver is as good as the great Heil AMT. I'm still not sure, but it is close.

I've heard very good things about the AMT-PRO.

I am thinking about a similar setup, just narrowing my decision down on which drivers to get. I was thinking about a WTW or TWW set up. I'm almost there.

Pics, if you have any...?


bladesmith

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 1378
  • water quenching steel since 2001....
    • palmer knives
Re: OB with Twin Alphas and Heil AMT
« Reply #21 on: 27 Mar 2015, 05:25 am »
For various reasons, I settled on the following for my latest OB experiment:

One Alpha 15A
One Dayton AMTPRO-4

Baffles are ~ 20" wide, 42 inches tall. They are tapered so they are ~12 inches wide at the top of the panel.
Currently using a simple coil/cap arrangement with the drivers rolling in/out around 4-5 KHz.

With this arrangement, I guess I just got lucky with the efficiency/xover points/slopes and the drivers match well with no need for padding down the AMT.

I can post pix if anyone is interested but so far, I am very impressed with how good these sound.  I am still using a sealed ML sub for < 50 Hz. Setting up a local listening panel soon to A/B these with Maggies, Logans, and a few other single driver setups. You really need to discount the pride factor when you build your own. But right now I would say that these are Maggie killers. All of the open and boxless sound of Maggies with much more bass, efficiency, depth, dynamics, and better and more extended highs.

I have also been trying to determine if the AMTPRO driver is as good as the great Heil AMT. I'm still not sure, but it is close.

From what I have researched and what I know about that AMTPRO and those Alpha 15A's. That simple design is going to sound very nice. I wouldn't be surprised if they sound incredible. I am just completely surprised how well OB speakers sound.
OB speakers are just one of those things that you have to hear for your self to believe. And from my own experimenting/experience, I won't go back to a box speaker, ever.  :D
 

InfernoSTi

Re: OB with Twin Alphas and Heil AMT
« Reply #22 on: 27 Mar 2015, 12:49 pm »
My "all Hawthorne" setup has the Hawthorne AMT-500 crossed at 500 Hz and two 15" Hawthorne SSI mid-drivers in MTM configuration and two 15" Hawthorne Augies biamped on separate towers PER side.  Sounds sublime...

The AMT dipole is a wonderful choice.



John

Guy 13

Re: OB with Twin Alphas and Heil AMT
« Reply #23 on: 27 Mar 2015, 12:54 pm »
Hi John,
may I know with what amplifiers you drive those nice Hawthorn speakers?

Guy 13

InfernoSTi

Re: OB with Twin Alphas and Heil AMT
« Reply #24 on: 28 Mar 2015, 01:43 am »
Guy,

Thanks for the question.  I used to use either a modified Bottlehead Stereomour 2A3 amp (3.5 watts) or modified Bottlehead Paramount 300B mono blocks (8 watts) when I had it "not" MTM (just MT) but after making the move to MTM, I find I have a difficult load...the efficiency is still nearly 100 dB but the load is complex.  The picture shows the BH 300B amps.  I have two different crossovers, one for the MT and one for the MTM configuration.  The drivers stay in the baffles, just the crossovers switch (the crossovers are mounted on nice plinths that are separate from the speakers and are pre-wired with Grover Huffman "umbilicals" to connect to the drivers). 

With the MTM configuration, I have Quicksilver Silver 88 mono blocks and a Pass Labs XA-30.5 amp.   Both are excellent but I find the Pass Labs XA-30.5 is in the rig nearly all the time these days.

John

Guy 13

Re: OB with Twin Alphas and Heil AMT
« Reply #25 on: 28 Mar 2015, 01:46 am »
Guy,

Thanks for the question.  I used to use either a modified Bottlehead Stereomour 2A3 amp (3.5 watts) or modified Bottlehead Paramount 300B mono blocks (8 watts) when I had it "not" MTM (just MT) but after making the move to MTM, I find I have a difficult load...the efficiency is still nearly 100 dB but the load is complex. 

So I have Quicksilver Silver 88 mono blocks and a Pass Labs XA-30.5 amp.   Both are excellent but I find the Pass Labs XA-30.5 is in the rig nearly all the time these days. 

John

Thanks John.

Guy 13

InfernoSTi

Re: OB with Twin Alphas and Heil AMT
« Reply #26 on: 28 Mar 2015, 01:48 am »
Guy,

I modified my post a little to give more detail...

I really enjoy your posts, by the way. I just wanted to tell you that since we have not spoken with each other much. 

John

bladesmith

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 1378
  • water quenching steel since 2001....
    • palmer knives
Re: OB with Twin Alphas and Heil AMT
« Reply #27 on: 28 Mar 2015, 04:30 am »
John,

The discussion about open baffle speakers is pretty controversial and well debated. I have tried a Eminence Delta 15FLA speaker in a flat baffle. (No H/U/wings, etc, etc.) And it produces wonderful low end, I'm not sure how, but it sounds wonderful.

I also wanted to complement you on your finish, the rich darker finish looks great.

V....
« Last Edit: 28 Mar 2015, 10:14 am by bladesmith »

InfernoSTi

Re: OB with Twin Alphas and Heil AMT
« Reply #28 on: 29 Mar 2015, 04:44 am »
OB low end is not boomy...so what it misses in the lowest octave and in pressure, it makes up for in musicality, in my opinion.  There is a different loading of the room than with a box sub.  I've posted this link recently elsewhere but I think it covers the "why" as well as anything I've read.

http://www.linkwitzlab.com/rooms.htm

Quote
By far the perceptually most uniform response in the range below 200 Hz is obtained with an open-baffle, dipole or figure-of-eight radiating source. Because of its directionality, the dipole excites far fewer room resonances than an omni-directional source. The measured room response is not necessarily any smoother than that for an omni-directional source. But the perceived difference in bass reproduction is startling at first, because we are so used to hearing the irregular and booming bass of the typical box speaker in acoustically small rooms. Quickly one learns to recognize the distortion of this combination and it becomes intolerable.

Thank you for the nice comment on the finish. Mike (Woodsage) in Seattle made those for me out of solid Sapele.  They are quite thick.  The photo does not do them justice...

John

Horizons

  • Restricted
  • Posts: 275
Re: OB with Twin Alphas and Heil AMT
« Reply #29 on: 31 Mar 2015, 08:28 pm »
Well, I finally gave up on the AMTPRO. It is a really nice driver but the Heil AMT has a more extended top end and just sounds more real. I am also back to biamping, using dbx analog LR4 at ~1400 Hz. Sounds wonderful.  I will probably use the AMTPRO for a pair of rear channels.

I can't imagine ever going back to a box speaker. And there is no longer the need to compromise the bass with a planer driver like the Maggie. Cones free of boxes sound much better than Maggies IMO.

bladesmith

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 1378
  • water quenching steel since 2001....
    • palmer knives
Re: OB with Twin Alphas and Heil AMT
« Reply #30 on: 3 Jun 2015, 03:31 pm »
Thanks for the info. The Hawthorne thread is interesting with an Alpha 15 crossed to the AMT at 5K. I already own a pair of AMTs and a pair of Ed's horns. Its a great match but I miss the OB sound of my old Emerald Physics clones. Those had an OB pair of Alphas with a compression driver crossed at 1K. I have heard the Alpha's crossed at 1 K and never had a problem with them. My current AMT/horns use Ed's series xover and are roughly crossed around 1K too.  I'm very tempted to just try 2 15-inch Alphas on a simple OB and electronically crossed to the AMT around 1 K.  I don't think you get the magic of the AMT if crossed at 5KHz.

Very helpful responses.


After researching and working on a set of OB speakers myself, I would say that your set up would work nicely.

I am using a ribbon tweeter (G1 Aurum Cantus) crossed at 2000hz, with a 10" Morel woofer. Those Morels (made in Israel.) are the same model that www.pureaudioproject.com uses, and they are hard working and very nice. I use one amp for the G1/Morel and I have another amp driving an Eminence Delta 15FLA woofer to support the low end. (The 15FLA has a low pass filter of 180hz.)

 

My system isn't exactly like yours, but you get the idea. I experimented with a x-over at 1600hz, because the Morel has a bit of a spike at that frequency, but it just worked/sounded better at 2khz. Both drivers, G1/Morel have very accurate specs available, unlike some manufacturers.

Did you end up trying two woofers or did you stay with one ?

V....

Zeev (PureAudioProject)

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 5
Re: OB with Twin Alphas and Heil AMT
« Reply #31 on: 24 Oct 2015, 08:38 pm »

After researching and working on a set of OB speakers myself, I would say that your set up would work nicely.

I am using a ribbon tweeter (G1 Aurum Cantus) crossed at 2000hz, with a 10" Morel woofer. Those Morels (made in Israel.) are the same model that www.pureaudioproject.com uses, and they are hard working and very nice. I use one amp for the G1/Morel and I have another amp driving an Eminence Delta 15FLA woofer to support the low end. (The 15FLA has a low pass filter of 180hz.)

 

My system isn't exactly like yours, but you get the idea. I experimented with a x-over at 1600hz, because the Morel has a bit of a spike at that frequency, but it just worked/sounded better at 2khz. Both drivers, G1/Morel have very accurate specs available, unlike some manufacturers.

Did you end up trying two woofers or did you stay with one ?

V....

Hi Bladesmith and everybody,

I just joined AudioCircle, after our Trio10 MundorfAMT made it to AudioCircle 'Best of RMAF 2015' and saw this thread... so this is my first post here...

The Morel 10" you have do look the same but have different parameters from our PAP1075. These were modified by Morel specifically for Open Baffle, e.g. Qts-1.14, Xmax: +/-4.75mm, see compete spec:https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B36Kyv2xZFCtYWhmVjA0a0M4Z1U.
These woofers play powerful, fast and clean deep bass and at the same time are sweet mid performers that can be taken up to 6.5khz and they are used by us in all our Trio10 models.
quote: "these speakers had it all – superb soundstage, perfect tonality, super open spacious sound that just destroys the walls in the room, all things that great open baffle speakers give you. But, what set this system apart was the laser like focus and lack of “misty” presentation almost every OB speaker has. Plus BASS SLAM. I know you never thought you’d see the words bass slam and Open Baffle ever uttered together. But there it is. I am an OB lover, it’s what I’ve run in my home system for years and years and so I’m a bit jaded about them. But this room raised the bar substantially over every other available OB system I’ve heard. Massive congrats to them for this achievement.”, Audio Circle, PEZ, Best of RMAF 2015, http://www.audiocircle.com/index.php?topic=137753.0

Trio10 MundorfAMT with PAP1075, OB 10" woofers and Mundorf AMT23D6.1




Trio10 MundorfAMT Crossovers

These woofers easily integrate with Heil AMT but we didn't design the XO for this particular configuration yet. Bi amping is no issue though !

Trio10 HeilAMT Configuration



Re the thread title: 'OB with Twin Alphas and Heil AMT'.
We integrated the Heil AMT with our OB-A15neo woofers, that are our custom Eminence upgrades to the Alpha15a http://www.pureaudioproject.com/product/15inch-open-baffle-bass-woofers/, since these upgraded drivers sound and play well up to 1khz (and even a bit more). We offer the Trio15 HeilAMT as a complete product and offer DIYers the OB-A15neo woofers, the Frames and woodwork plans. see our web www.pureaudioproject.com

Trio15 HeilAMT