Hi Samurai7595,
I had this exact issue with a Samsung SSD in a BDP2. I reconnected the drive to my Mac, formatted it to MS-DOS (I believe that you must also choose Master Boot Record for an internal BDP2 drive), ejected it when done and reinstalled it in the BDP2. The second attempt worked like a charm and I was then able to format the disc to EXT3 using the format utility within Manic Moose. No further issues.
So I suspect there was an issue with the initial formatting of your hard drive.
Hope I helped!
DJ