I will look forward to seeing your notes. I assume all of this testing is being performed "sighted"?
I am really curious if you've tested with the JitterBug in an unused port - not necessarily one of the ports being used by the flash drive. I ask because AudioQuest makes the case that the JitterBug can "clean up" noise from the USB bus, even plugged into an unused port. I am skeptical that much noise is generated by a flash drive, although it does draw *some* power, so maybe there is a benefit.
Yeah this has been all sighted. It's quite hard to setup blind tests with the Jitterbug, especially when used with the BDP-1. On the computer, you have to make sure that the USB port is the same one each time you plug and unplug. Nothing else plugged in to other ports. All unnecessary apps closed. Wifi off. Audirvana running full System Optimization.
On the BDP-1, if you unplug and plug back in, the music and directory stops working and with a huge library it take time to reset it. The work around I found was to actually stop MPD and start Roon Ready. During that time you can unplug and plug drives back in and then restart MPD and the directory will still be there. It's the fastest method I've found so far.
All of these things isn't something a family member can easily help me out with. With cables and toggling buttons for comparing inputs, that's a lot easier than dealing with Macs and BDP-1 and MPD and Manic Moose.
I have gone and back and forth on the flash drive vs hard drive thing way before I knew of the Jitterbug and other noise stuff. It was always a toss up because of the trade-offs that I've noticed all along. So I don't think it's some bias I developed in anticipation of the Jitterbug and other knowledge.
The two Jitterbugs is also interesting, and I might give that a go if/when I get another piece. Most likely, I'll be using one with iMac and another with drives. Two is the limit on a bus drive. I'm not sure of BDP-1's USB schematics and how many and where I can put at a time.
Although, regarding the location of the flash and hard drives on BDP-1, I didn't find any differences in sound quality if a flash drive is plugged in the back or front. I plug the WD Drive in the rear bottom location. The flash drives typically go at the front. Another place where I didn't find a difference is if both flash drives and hard drives are plugged in at the same time or only one at a time. No difference if say the hard drive is plugged in the bottom rear permanently, and then I move the flash drive to either the 2 front ports or the rear top. So bottom line for me was no difference in sound with respect to location.
If I had to make a guess on which configurations would be the easiest and which would be the toughest to pick up in a blind test, I would say that configuration #1 with the iMac would be the easiest. The hardest would be the 2 TB WD portable hard drive. Flash drive in the middle.