IRD in contrast to Channel Islands and Bel Canto

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 2986 times.

Angaria

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 334
IRD in contrast to Channel Islands and Bel Canto
« on: 19 Nov 2006, 06:51 am »
I just stumbled upon IRD as I was trying to decide between the channel islands d-100 and bel canto s300.  Both are well reviewed class D amps, but for apparently half their used prices, the MB-100's definitely piqued my interested.  Always excited to "discover" excellent products a student can afford.

Has anyone a/b'd these with class d amps before?  Thanks.

NealH

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 373
Re: IRD in contrast to Channel Islands and Bel Canto
« Reply #1 on: 19 Nov 2006, 11:09 am »
I own the Bel Canto evo-4 and, in my opinion it is an excellent amplifier.  Driving ribbon speakers like Magnepan, it was the best amplifier that I used.  It excels driving B & W's too.  Zero grain, even response, very extended, transparent and powerful.   

I believe the IRD is a conventional amplifier (class AB).  I am sure it's very good too but, after going through several conventional amps, I doubt it will be too much different than the others - some traits they tend to share.  One area they may have an edge is in depth.  The soundstage depth seemed better with the better conventional amps.  The transparency and immediacy seemed much better with the BC.   

Having said this, there are many amplifiers on the market today and, generalizing is probably not a good practice anymore.  As in speakers or any other component for that matter, preferences will play a large part.  If possible, try before you buy.  Look for the companies that offer money back trials.  I don't like returning an item any more than someone else but, in this hobby there isn't a way around it if we are intent on assembling that magical and often elusive system.  Several circle vendors offer a money back trial (NuForce, IRD (I think), Channel Islands, etc).